The Ratings Game: Marathon Oil’s stock falls after Morgan Stanley downgrades to rare bearish rating
The Ratings Game
Analyst turns bearish on shares a day after Moody’s turns negative on credit rating, putting it danger of ‘junk’ status
Shares of Marathon Oil Corp. sold off Tuesday, to pull back from the previous session’s 10-week closing high, after Morgan Stanley turned bearish on the oil-and-natural gas company, citing concerns about high debt levels and a more challenged outlook.
Analysts led by Devin McDermott downgraded the stock to a rare underweight rating from neutral. He kept his stock price target at $5, which is 14% below current levels.
For Morgan Stanley, an underweight rating expresses the analyst’s belief that the stock’s return over the next 12 to 18 months will be below the average return of its peers. Of the 3,204 stocks covered by Morgan Stanley analysts, only 553, or 17%, are rated underweight, compared with 45% at equal weight and 38% at overweight.
“While the company is taking the right steps to preserve liquidity in response to low oil prices, [Marathon Oil] screens challenged versus peers with a 2021 [West Texas Intermediate] break-even of $37 a barrel (in the upper half of our coverage), and year-end 2021 leverage that rises to 4.5X at strip, above the peer median of approximately 2X,” McDermott wrote in a note to clients.
Marathon Oil’s stock
dropped 4.3% to $5.82 on Tuesday, after running up 8.4% on Monday to the highest close since May 6, amid a broad rally in the energy sector and stock market. Year to date, the stock has tumbled 57.1%, while the SPDR Energy Select Sector exchange-traded fund
has shed 37.0% and the S&P 500 index
has lost 9.5%.
Meanwhile, continuous crude-oil futures for WTI
rose 0.5% to $31.82 on Tuesday, but were down 47.9% this year amid concerns over a supply glut and lower demand as a result of th COVID-19 pandemic. See Futures Movers.
McDermott said Marathon Oil’s stock valuation is roughly in line with the company’s North American peers. He said that valuation is “unwarranted” given the company’s “more challenged outlook.”
Earlier this month, Marathon Oil reported an adjusted first-quarter loss that matched expectations while revenue rose above forecasts. But the company withdrew its full-year financial guidance, citing uncertainties over the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, and nearly halved its capital spending budget for the year to $1.3 billion. The company has also suspended payment of a dividend and share repurchases.
Morgan Stanley’s downgrade comes a day after credit rating service Moody’s Investors Service changed its outlook Marathon Oil’s credit to negative from stable, the company’s deteriorating credit metrics and exposure to continued low oil prices. A negative outlook suggests the next rating move will more likely be a downgrade.
Since Moody’s rates Marathon Oil’s credit at Baa3, which is the lowest investment grade rating, a downgrade would put the rating into speculative grade, or “junk” territory.
S&P Global Ratings has rated Marathon Oil’s credit at BBB-, also the firm’s lowest investment grade rating, with a negative outlook since it downgraded the credit from BBB on March 26.