Small investors and pension funds might be collateral damage, says economist who predicted coronavirus danger
In late February, two Federal Reserve officials, Cleveland Fed President Loretta Mester and Fed Vice Chairman Richard Clarida, spoke at a conference of top economists in Washington to give their outlook for the economy. Asked about the coronavirus, the officials said it was too early to tell how it might affect the U.S. economy.
As the audience filed out, Carl Tannenbaum, chief economist at Northern Trust, looked stricken.
The Fed was being ”tone-deaf,“ Tannenbaum said. Conventional wisdom — that the economy was going to have a short downturn, followed by a quick pickup — was very optimistic, he said.
A month later, Tannenbaum sighs when reminded of our conversation.
“No one could have predicted how prophetic that turned out to be,” he said.
Looking at the aggressive Fed actions over the past few weeks, Tannenbaum said he was impressed.
“The Fed got off to a slow start but got up to a sprint very quickly,” he said.
In addition to cutting its benchmark rate close to zero, the Fed has thrown the kitchen sink at the credit markets, trying to get money to all corners of the financial markets including municipal bonds, student loans, and commercial paper.
Only a few weeks ago, there a concern that the reforms Congress engineered in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis would have hamstrung the central bank during the next crisis. But that turned out not to be.
“If there is any impairment to Fed powers, it has not been apparent,” Tannenbaum said.
The Fed’s actions are aimed in part at breaking the sense of fear that has gripped financial markets, with investors seeking cash. Everyday Americans who are not investors need to know that helping out markets is helping Main Street, he said.
“The broad failure of the financial system is no good for anybody,” Tannenbaum said.
But Congress must follow through with stimulus to drive the message hope that this isn’t just about helping Wall Street, and that there would be help for average Americans, he said.
Some of the small business loans and direct checks under consideration seem a bit clunky and Tannenbaum worries that the relief won’t arrive until too late.
“It could be weeks before relief gets out. How many businesses are going to be at the breaking point?” he asked.
Mass layoffs would slow any recovery.
Tannenbaum said he hoped there would be some sort of national holiday for credit card payments or mortgages would be just the direct relief that some families are desperately hoping for.
It was also good news that there hasn’t been the need for any bailouts, Tannenbaum said. Banks look to be in strong position.
Going forward, Tannenbaum said he would be watching closely to see if any shadow banks, like hedge funds and mutual funds, or if investment products struggle.
There could be a ‘democracy” of loss if some small investors or pension funds invested in risky products, or firms.
“Some small investors or [pension] funds might own hedge funds or mutual funds who could struggle in the weeks ahead,” he said
In 1994, Orange County California had to file for bankruptcy after billions of dollars in Wall Street loans tied to risky derivative made to its investment fund went sour after a surprise Fed interest-rate hike.
Paraphrasing Warren Buffett, the tide has gone out and we’re about to find out who was swimming without a swim suit, Tannenbaum said.
The Fed’s hundreds of billion of dollars in loans programs are aimed at preventing “that kind of crack” in the financial system, he said.
U.S. equity benchmarks finished sharply higher on Tuesday on hopes of a quick end to negotiations over a roughly $1.8 trillion coronavirus stimulus package. The Dow Jones Industrial Average
soared over 11%.